How to tell if your marketing agency is working

If the report stops at leads, you can't tell. The cheapest leads are often the most expensive bookings. What to ask for instead.

To tell whether your marketing agency is working, look at what it reports. If the report stops at leads and cost per lead, you can't tell. Ask for cost per booking and cost per patient started, by ad and by month. The cheapest leads are often the most expensive patients, and the leads that cost more often book for less.

Here is what to look for in an agency report, the questions to ask, and a real example of why lead cost misleads.

The cheapest leads were the most expensive bookings

One practice came to us after a previous agency. Its doctor remembered leads costing $14 to $17. That was true for the best weeks. Across the whole run, the real cost was about $27 per lead, and only 15% of those leads booked a visit. That worked out to about $182 per booking.

In our first weeks on the same account, leads cost more, about $50 each. But 38% of them booked, so each booking cost about $134.

Previous agencyFirst weeks with us
Cost per leadAbout $27About $50
Booked rate15%38%
Cost per bookingAbout $182About $134

We see the same pattern across accounts.

A report built on cost per lead would have ranked all of these backwards.

Why cheap leads often book worse

  • Free and discounted offers. A free consultation or a low-price visit gets a lot of form fills. Many come from people who want the free thing, not a care plan. That same practice's doctor said the free offer brought no-shows and patients who couldn't pay.
  • Easy forms. The fewer questions a form asks, the cheaper the lead and the less you know about whether they're a fit.
  • Ads tuned for form fills. Meta and Google learn to find people who fill out forms. Unless they're told who booked, they keep finding more form fillers.

A lead that costs more because the ad was specific about the condition, the evaluation and the cost often books at a much higher rate. What matters is the cost per booking.

Check whether the report's lead count is real

That same account had a second problem. For much of the run, the ad platform counted thank-you page views as leads. People who refreshed the page or submitted twice were counted twice. Over the whole period, Meta reported about 12% more leads than the practice actually received.

Ask your agency where its lead count comes from. Then compare it, month by month, with the number of new inquiries in your own scheduling or CRM system. If the two don't match, the report's cost per lead is wrong too.

What a good agency report shows

NumberWhy it matters
SpendWhat you paid the platforms this month
Leads, matched to your systemReal inquiries, not platform events
Booked rate and cost per bookingWhether leads turn into visits
Show rateWhether booked visits happen
Patients started and cost per patient startedWhat a new patient actually costs
All of the above by ad or campaignWhich ads to keep, even if their leads cost more

If your report has only the first two rows, the agency is reporting on the part of the work that's easiest to measure. Why cost per lead is the wrong number to run a practice on explains the full set of numbers.

Seven questions to ask your agency

  1. What is our cost per booking this month, and how has it changed over the last three months?
  2. Which ad has the best cost per booking, and which has the worst? Are they the same as the best and worst cost per lead?
  3. Where does your lead count come from, and does it match our system?
  4. What happens to a lead in the first hour after it comes in? Who follows up, and how fast?
  5. Does the ad platform know which leads booked, or only which ones filled out a form?
  6. What offer are the ads running, and why?
  7. If we spend 30% more next month, what do you expect to happen to cost per booking?

A good agency answers these quickly, with numbers. If the answer to most of them is "we'd have to look into that", you've learned what you needed to know.

What to do if your report only shows leads

You don't need to switch agencies to get the answer. Pull last month's ad leads from your own system, mark which ones booked and which ones started care, and divide the ad spend by each. It takes an afternoon. If the cost per patient started is higher than a new patient is worth to you, you have a problem no lead report would have shown. The math on booked rate shows how to put a value on it.

Questions about judging a marketing agency

What should a clinic's marketing report include?

Spend, real leads matched to your own system, booked rate, cost per booking, show rate, patients started and cost per patient started, broken down by ad or campaign.

Is a low cost per lead a good sign?

Not on its own. In our accounts, the cheapest leads often booked the worst. Judge an agency on cost per booking and cost per patient started.

Why would leads that cost more be better?

Ads that are specific about the condition, the evaluation and the cost discourage people who aren't a fit. Fewer people fill out the form, but more of them book and show up.

How often should I review my agency's results?

Cost per booking monthly, and cost per patient started over a rolling quarter, since care decisions can take weeks.

Talk to us

Not sure your agency is working?

Send us your last report. We'll tell you what it shows, what it leaves out, and what your cost per booking really is.

Have us review my report