Why discount specials bring the wrong patients, and what to lead with

A $37 first visit fills the schedule with people who want the $37 visit. What to lead with instead, and when a lower price makes sense.

Discount specials bring in people who want the discount. A $37 first visit or a free consultation fills the schedule, but many of those people never start a care plan, and some never show. For cash-based care, lead with the problem you solve, the doctor who'll examine them and a real evaluation. You'll get fewer leads and more patients.

Why specials look like they work

A discount ad almost always produces cheaper leads. The cost per lead drops, the schedule fills, and the report looks great. The trouble shows up later: in show rate, in start rate, and in the revenue per new patient.

One practice that came to us had run a free consultation offer through its previous agency. The doctor's own words afterward: it brought no-shows and patients who couldn't pay. On paper the leads were cheap. In the office they were expensive.

What a discount says about the care

A $37 first visit tells the patient this is a $37 decision. When the doctor then recommends a care plan that costs thousands, the gap is jarring. The patient came for the deal, and the plan feels like a bait and switch, even when it isn't.

Leading with the evaluation sets the right expectation from the start: this is a medical decision, a doctor will look at your case, and you'll get an honest answer about whether we can help.

What to lead with instead

Instead ofLead with
"$37 new patient special""Non-surgical care for nerve pain, starting with a full evaluation by a doctor"
"Free consultation""Find out if you're a candidate"
"50% off your first visit"A real patient explaining why they chose the clinic

The evaluation can still be priced fairly, and some clinics include imaging or a detailed report to make it worth booking. The point is that the offer is the evaluation and the doctor, not the price.

Where a lower price can make sense

  • A paid evaluation with real value, such as a full exam and a written plan, priced fairly. That's not a discount. It's a product.
  • Bringing past patients back, as a thank-you, not as the main message. See bringing past patients back without discounts for why even that usually isn't needed.
  • A test. If you want to try an offer, judge it on cost per patient started, not cost per lead.

How to tell if your special is hurting you

  1. Compare show rate for leads that came in on the special with leads that didn't.
  2. Compare start rate the same way.
  3. Work out cost per patient started for each.

If the special wins on cost per lead and loses on cost per patient started, it's costing you money. Why cost per lead is the wrong number to run a practice on shows how to work it out.

Questions about new patient specials

Do new patient specials work for chiropractic clinics?

They bring in leads, but for cash-based care they often lower show rates and start rates. Judge them on cost per patient started, not cost per lead.

Should a clinic charge for the first evaluation?

Many cash-based clinics charge a fair price for a thorough evaluation. A real price signals a real medical visit and attracts people ready to decide.

What should my ad offer instead of a discount?

A clear evaluation by a named doctor, a statement of who the care is for, and an invitation to find out whether they're a candidate.

Talk to us

Running a special that isn't paying off?

We'll help you compare cost per patient started with and without it, and what to lead with instead.

Talk about my offer